Rohan (Middle-earth) - Wikipedia
Not only have Arnor and Rohan always been two distinct entities, they had As a reward for Rohan's actions, Cirion, the Steward of Gondor. This world comprised of Mordor, Gondor, Rohan, and many other places. . There are even some people who suggest that their relationship. Rohan (from Sindarin Rochand) is a kingdom in J. R. R. Tolkien's fantasy setting of Middle-earth. It is mainly a grassland, and lies north-west of its ally Gondor, and further .. Rohirric bears a similar relationship to Westron, the Common Speech of Middle-earth, as that of Old English to modern English, and so Tolkien .
As a bonus, it always happened in the middle of the night. Instead of just counting the time between… Turn or go straight? This is a classic problem. You are in a car heading straight towards a wall. Should you try to stop or should you try to turn to avoid the wall?
Let me assume that I can use the normal model of… Basketball shot - real or fake? I have seen several videos similar to this. How many tries did this take? Let the analysis begin. Before I do any analysis, let me state that I think this is not fake. I do not know that for sure, just my first guess. How would I tell if it is real or fake?
What Lord of the Rings Human Kingdom do you belong to?
I can'… My question is, how long did it take you to put together this blog post: It looks like you are enjoying your summer! By Fran not verified on 30 Jul permalink This system sounds similar to a Napoleonic semaphore line. The Wiki article mentions that average transmission time between Paris and Lille km over mostly flat terrain via 15 stations was 32 minutes weather-dependent, obviouslyand that was for a message with content.
Of course this was with trained military personnel specifically looking for transmissions from the neighboring stations on the line, and did not involve lighting fires. At its peak, the French system included stations covering about km of lines. Comparing with your New York-Raleigh estimate, the required number of stations is close in the high 40sbut typical transmission times would be much shorter, around minutes.
Suspend your incredulity for a few hours. Also, the movie departs seriously from the book on many occasions. The book is far more entertaining. Read it 3 times so far. Log in to post comments By djlactin not verified on 30 Jul permalink I don't have any problem with the length of time it took for the signal to be noticed at each station. Watching for the signal is their job, and presumably everyone knows it's a time of high tension, and there's a reasonable expectation that the fire might be lit soon.
For comparison - I supervise lifeguards. Lifeguards are expected to recognize a drowning swimmer within 10 seconds. We test this by having swimmers release a rubber duck and record how long it takes the guard to notice the duck they signal when they see it. That requires them to notice the appearance of a new object in what is frequently a crowded field of view, and our guards manage this in 10 seconds more frequently than not.
The fire appearing should be an easier spot, since it's going to involve major, eye-attracting motion. Log in to post comments By Mike Dunford not verified on 30 Jul permalink You have forgotton one clear and crucial element: So, while it may appear that only 12 seconds pass between the lighting of one beacon and the lighting of the next, in reality, it might be reasonable to calculate, say, several hours.
The only one that mattered was the first to the second because this was the unauthorised lighting, it had to be noticed before being extinguished. After than, hours might elapse without dire consequences. By AnyEdge not verified on 30 Jul permalink Great post! Given that Tolkien was not much of a scientist, I've found he got stuff wrong in a number of places. However, I think your real-world estimates here are reasonable- 14 hours or so to send a signal about miles is close to Tolkien's story line.
The maps have Minas Tirith and Edoras about leagues miles apart. If I remember correctly it took Gandalf about 3 days to ride that.
Log in to post comments By Martin Madsen not verified on 30 Jul permalink You're also assuming that all the other lightings were close to the average speed.
Perhaps it shows it at night because at one or more stations the watchers were asleep, or had gone out for the afternoon.
Maybe they were fighting orcs or reciting some really tedious elvish poetry. So you have this extremely well-transmitted message with a couple of six-hour speedbumps in it. Log in to post comments By Ben not verified on 30 Jul permalink Well, they say it's six days of hard riding from Rohan to Gondor. A good horse can do miles in 24 h, this being a movie, it can do it 6 times in a row.
This makes the maximum distance miles. So the circumference of middle earth must be significantly smaller than earth. Since the gravity seems close to standard, you've just proven middle earth has a lead core. Log in to post comments By Mu not verified on 30 Jul permalink 8: Shadowfax is far, far more than a mere 'good horse'. By AnyEdge not verified on 30 Jul permalink Just to be geeky. And they are pretty much at opposite ends of a mountain range The White Mountainsso there is a nice line of peaks between them.
Also, Middle Earth is supposed to be Earth, so when wondering about the length of day and night, you can use real world answers. Also when Gandalf and Pippin ride to Gondor, they ride on Shadowfax, a horse that does not tire it's magic, dontchaknow so a horse galloping at about 35 mph over various terrain gets there in hours.
Log in to post comments By Aaron not verified on 30 Jul permalink There is a real world example you can compare this with. The great wall of China had this warning system and could pass a message across it's length within a day.
The established distance between Edoras and Minas Tirith is closer to miles, as the crow flies miles by horse, via the Great West Road. Also, the book lists only seven beacons, excluding the one in Minas Tirith itself. I guess fires are hyper-visible in the White Mountains air. By the Rising Jurist not verified on 30 Jul permalink I think the Great Wall of China was meant to have signal fires lit along it to pass similar information across.
I bet more real-world data could be gathered from that realistic situation. By CalcDave not verified on 30 Jul permalink According to LotR, the northern beacon system consisted of 7 stations extending west from Minas Tirith: There was also a southern system to warn the seaward provinces. Of course the system ended at Halifirien on the Gondor-Rohan border, so unless the Rohirrim relief force is camped there waiting for a signal to cross the border your signal must be carried by mounted rider to Edoras, which is about another miles.
Minas Tirith to the Fords of Isen is about leagues.
- For all things Tolkien, The Lord Of The Rings, The Hobbit, Silmarillion, and more ...
- Rohan (Middle-earth)
Osgiliath to Bree by the Numenorean road is stated as being leagues in the essay on the Disaster of the Gladden Fields. However, I am not really enjoying my summer because it has been too busy with not enough time for blogging. But, summer classes just ended, so maybe I can get some stuff done. Log in to post comments By rallain on 30 Jul permalink Knowing Tolkein's background, I suspect he modeled the fires after the 4th century B. Jewish tradition of lighting fires from mountaintop to mountaintop to signal the new month Rosh Chodesh.
The fires were lit when a silver of new moon was visible in Jerusalem and the final fire was visible in Babylon Iraq. The distance was about miles.
I couldn't find enough information at the University of Google to make a useful calculation, but it was well less than a day until protesting groups starting setting other beacon fires to try to confuse the system Log in to post comments By bsci not verified on 30 Jul permalink To all: Let me just say that these are great comments.
This is why I write this kind of stuff. Nothing like a good geeky conversation about physics and Lord of the Rings. Log in to post comments By rallain on 30 Jul permalink Should have used the mountains in New Zealand for reference, as they're where the movie was filmed. Log in to post comments By Kitty not verified on 30 Jul permalink In the passage where Pippin sees the signal fires in Return of the King, Gandalf states that each beacon location is also a relay station for errand riders, capable of providing fresh mounts.
Given that the northern system only extends halfway to Edoras, that Rohan needs more info and deserves more diplomatic courtesy than a contentless signal fire could provide, and that the formal request for aid was is fact delivered by errand riders, it is likely that the beacon system was only used to warn Gondorian residents of Anorien the province along the first miles of road, up to the border with Rohan.
It seems unlikely that Anorien would be uninhabited in peacetime; warning the population would allow them to head for refuges in the mountains and send reinforcements to Minas Tirith. He stopped for a few hours at Edoras call it 6.
Gondor | The One Wiki to Rule Them All | FANDOM powered by Wikia
The ring has the power to corrupt the mind of anyone it comes into contact with, and people start getting really attached to the ring. They get obsessed over it, and want to keep it for themselves at any cost. But the ring also has other powers. These powers can give the wearer abilities, but at a cost.
But is it true that the ring can make the wearer invisible? He wants it back in his grasp more than anything, and even constructs a tower which has a massive eye. This is definitely one of the more disturbing parts of the Lord Of The Rings movie, and the eye is constantly darting around in a sickening fashion, searching in vain for the ring of power.
At the start of the movie, it doesn't know where the ring is. But is it true that Sauron cannot see the wearer of the ring? He lives through this impact because he's wearing a rare and expensive shirt of mithril, given to him by the elves to protect him.
It's light as a feather, but stronger than any other metal known to man. For this reason, it's perfect for protecting someone like Frodo. But what creature delivers the blow that almost kills him? He can't just wear it on his finger, as that would attract attention from Sauron and the tower of the eye.
The way Frodo wears and transport the ring also allows him to hide it from the public's view, as he must keep the fact that he's in possession of the ring a secret. But how exactly does Frodo transport the ring? These factions have long histories of alliances, battles, and disputes with each other. One of the most well-known relationships is the one between the elves and the dwarves. Everyone in Middle Earth knows how the Elves and Dwarves feel about each other.
But is it true that they get along just fine? They try to pass the Misty Mountains, but must turn back after Saruman starts casting spells at them. Their only option is to go through the mountains, via the Mines of Moria. But to their horror, the mines are infested with dangerous creatures. What kind of creatures are these? There are undeniably one of the most evil groups in Middle Earth, and they are often used by Sauron to do his evil bidding. They are seen slaughtering humans, attacking the fellowship, and generally being a massive nuisance.
They spend more time attacking each other than their enemies, but their sheer numbers make them formidable foes. But is it true that orcs were originally elves, mutilated and tortured into a new form of horrific creature? Gandalf Gimli Boromir Each member of the fellowship has their own special personality.
Legolas is agile and quick, and is a master of archery. Gimli is incredibly tough, and never gives up. But there is one member of the fellowship who carries a horn. It is his signature item, one that has special meaning for him. He blows the horn right before his death to draw the orcs to him, away from the rest of the fellowship. But which member carries a horn?
Lord Of The Rings: Things You Didn't Know About Gondor
Uruk-Hai Goblins Mumakil Saruman is one of the most despicable characters in the entire series. He is actually a wizard, but he's been corrupted by a dark artifact. He ends up using his powers for evil, creating a vast army that allies with Saruman. His greatest achievement is the creation of a new breed of orcs. These orcs are taller, stronger and more disciplined than the normal Mordor Orcs.
They pose a great threat to the fellowship and all of humanity. But what are they called?
He makes an early appearance in the first film, traveling to the Shire to meet his old friend, Bilbo Baggins. These two have gone on adventures together in the past, but now Gandalf realizes that their past endeavors pale in comparison to what's ahead of them. He can be seen as the architect of the movement against Sauron, and he is a genius. But what was he called before he became Gandalf The White?
Rathgul Moria Mordor As previously mentioned, Saruman builds an incredible army of Uruk-Hai with the sole purpose of destroying mankind.
He turns his base into a war machine, churning out Uruk-Hai from massive underground spawning grounds. He also starts building advanced devices such as explosives and advanced swords and armor. This base of his is dominated by a massive tower at the center, from which he addresses his troops and gives orders to the marauding Uruk-Hai. But what is this base actually called?
They are essentially a horse tribe, and they value the lives of their horses so much that they hang their shields on the sides of their horses, rather than using the shields to protect themselves.
They are known for having some of the finest cavalry in Middle Earth, and their charges can be devastating. But do you know which group of humans this is?
Question 25 Complete The Legolas Quote: Almost every character in the movie has a quote that's capable of sending chills down your spine. It's just such an amazing script. One character who has a lot of cool lines is Legolas. Being an Elf, he sees things that many do not, both physically and philosophically. He is aware of the signs that happen all around him. Can you complete the quote when he sees the red sun rise? These battles are incredibly epic, and nothing had ever before been witnessed by movie goers at that time.
The scale of these battles were astronomical. One of the most exciting of these battles was a last stand made by humans and elves against the Uruk-Hai which had been sent to destroy them all. Although it was one of the bloodiest battles, it ended with the destruction of the Uruk-Hai. Where did this battle take place? But an even greater blow came when his base at Isengard was completely destroyed as well. This pretty much took Saruman out of the equation when it came to the future of the Middle Earth.
With one evil faction destroyed, the allies could turn their attention fully towards Mordor. But Isengard was destroyed by an unlikely group of creatures. Also known as tree people, these creatures lived in the forest and moved and spoke very slowly.
Merry and Pippin end up being captured by these creatures, although it's clear that the Ents mean them no harm. They do, however, spend days discussing a very trivial issue. Is it true that they initially think Merry and Pippin are orcs? Aragorn Legolas Gimli There is one warrior in the fellowship who capable of simply incredible feats of agility and martial prowess.
This member of the fellowship is an elf, and so is gifted with better reflexes and agility than other races of Middle Earth. But even among elves, this warrior is considered to be gifted in terms of his abilities. He pledges his bow to the fellowship, and this is a weapon with which he has incredible ability.